May, 2006

Why We Don't Get No Respect

 

(Many thanks go to Kit Brown, President of the Snake River STC chapter, for her invaluable assistance and many contributions to this article.)

 

A popular complaint from technical communicators is "We don't get no respect!" Yup, that's frequently true. In this article, I'm going to tell you why this is so and I'll give you a few tips on what you can do to ameliorate this.


Think back to the story of the "Emperor's New Clothes," a story everyone should be familiar with by now. At the end of the story, the little boy points out that the emperor is, in fact, naked. Pointing out the emperor's new clothes is an important concept but what's worth noting is that you never hear what happens to the little boy after the end of the story!

 

As technical communicators, we know. Many of us have the scars to prove it. While most other jobs are vertical, ours are horizontal. Our jobs take us throughout our companies and we talk to everyone. It's not hard to imagine a scenario where we might talk to a customer support group leader, a line engineer, the CEO, and someone in Shipping all in the same day for the same project. As a result, we hear that, while the engineers are creating something that stands upright and is painted blue, the marketers are planning a campaign for a product that lies on its side and is painted green.

 

The problem with all of this is that we inevitably become the bearers of bad news. And that brings us back to the Emperor's New Clothes. People do not take kindly to the bearers of bad news and we are often blamed for just doing our job (when someone else clearly wasn't doing theirs to have gotten the company into a mess like this). The underlying issue, is, of course, bad communication between the various vertical groups. Marketers and QA don't usually interact, nor do Training and Production, and engineers are legendary for not talking to anybody at all.

 

There are two ways you can not be the bearer of bad news. The first is to avoid bringing bad news from one group to another as best you can. This is possible some of the time: if you can get someone from Marketing to describe what they're doing within earshot of an engineering manager, you don't have to say a thing. (Machiavellian? You bet, but "better you than me!") However, people will catch on to you sooner or later and this could very easily backfire, so I wouldn't recommend it as a general policy.

 

A more proactive and positive way to deal with the problem is to do what you can to facilitate everyone's knowledge of what's happening in other parts of the company, at least the ones who are dealing with the project you're focusing on. Perhaps the best way to do this is to send out a regular newsletter or status report that compiles information about the project for each of the sections. This is definitely added work and borders on the dreaded "team secretary" role that most of us loathe, but it's a great way of keeping people looking at the actual groups and not the messenger. We can also gain a lot of personal respect for our performance and how we deal with things that will slowly spread to the perceptions of the jobs we do, but it's mostly uphill and can be a fragile reputation. The things that developers and engineers tend to respect us for most is our ability to come across as someone who has a technical background and not like (as one of my favorite program managers used to put it) "an artsy English major."

 

Other possible reasons for not getting respect on the job include:

  • Whining instead of problem solving
    It's been my experience that the people who complain the most about the lack of respect also tend to be the biggest whiners and the ones with the most negative energy.
  • Not marketing our successes
    Our jobs are invisible when we are doing them well, but we rarely toot our own horns. When things aren't done well, it's obvious to everyone. You only notice that the mechanics screwed up when the plane crashes. Worse, what we do is usually only accessed when all else fails, at which point the user is already feeling frustrated.
  • Not marketing our jobs
    It's difficult to explain what exactly we do to someone not in the profession. We do so much more than write and edit and create graphics, but for some reason we have a difficult time explaining it to our friends and relations. We're also fighting entrenched stupidity in engineers and managers who think that, because they can read and sometimes even create a well-formed sentence, they can write, too. I will point out that they can hum and tap their foot in time to music; does this make them Fred Astaire?

You can defuse a lot of this by marketing what you're doing and showing how it's making everyone's life better to the people you work with. Show the engineers why having good product documentation is important. Dazzle everyone with the clarity of the redesigned product UI that you did versus the old one. Get data from the support technicians to show how calls about a previously hot issue have reduced since the latest help file went out. And be positive!


No matter what we do, though, we're all going to take damage periodically because we were unfortunate enough to have flipped over the wrong rock. Take your lumps and figure that if you want more respect on the job than we get, you could always have gotten into teaching or nursing.

 

    

Previous Page
Top of Page
Next Page

 

To be removed from this distribution list, please send us an e-mail with the word UNSUBSCRIBE in the subject line.

 

www.stc-src.org